Register Log-in Investor Type

Defensives doing well

Jennifer Hill, AIC Compass, 8 April 2022:

Jennifer Hill analyses the sectors delivering robust returns.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine feels symbolic, not only of a marked change in the geopolitical landscape but also of a potential regime change in investing.

With oil, gas, wheat and many metals soaring in price, already-stubborn inflation is likely to prove persistently higher, cementing the reversal of a decade of subdued inflation and falling interest rates.

“That’s been good for some traditionally defensive areas, but not for others,” says Rob Morgan, chief analyst at Charles Stanley. “Questions surround conventional bonds, for instance, and their correlation with growth equities is a worry for those with 60/40 portfolios tilted to these.”

As investors scramble to diversify and hedge against a more inflationary outcome, which defensives are doing well?


A handful of investment trusts focus on listed natural resources companies. Two are managed by Blackrock – BlackRock World Mining and BlackRock Energy & Resources Income – and three by CQS: City Natural Resources Growth & Income (CYN), Geiger Counter (GCL) and Golden Prospect Precious Metals.

They have all been among the best-performing trusts in the year to date, with share price rises ranging from 28% at GCL to 38% at CYN…

Capital preservation

The flexible investment sector is home to a small band of capital preservation trusts – Ruffer, Capital Gearing (CGT), Personal Assets and RIT Capital – that have exposure to inflation hedges such as index-linked bonds and gold.

“These funds have lowish exposure to equities, but the equities that they do hold tend to be defensive – stocks such as Microsoft,” says James Carthew, head of investment companies at QuotedData.

Ruffer is the best-performing of the quartet so far this year, with its shares rising 6% in the first three months of the year. The chief drivers of performance have been gold and energy stocks, as well as protection in the form of two types of option – those that benefit from rising interest rates and those that profit from falling stock markets.

Read more here

Please review our cookie, privacy & data protection and terms and conditions policies and, if you accept, please select your place of residence and whether you are a private or professional investor.

You live in…

You are a…