News

Metage calls on VinaCapital Vietnam shareholders to vote down directors’ fee increase as protest for poor performance

Activist investor Metage Capital has published an open letter urging VinaCapital Vietnam Opportunity Fund (VOF) shareholders to vote against a proposed 30% increase in the fees its directors are paid. 

Ted Childs, portfolio manager at London-based Metage, objected to the resolution at the forthcoming annual general meeting in Guernsey on 3 December which would raise the cap on directors fees from $650,000 to $850,000.

He said the five-strong board was already paid “significantly more” than the average listed equity trust with the chair receiving two thirds more than the average £51,944 fee of comparable funds. 

“By voting against it, shareholders can register their opposition to the board’s continued failure to listen to its investors, while overseeing poor relative performance, receiving high remuneration and refusing a vote on the future of unlisted investments,” said Childs.

Since the £498m investment company’s last discontinuation vote on 6 December 2023, shareholders had seen underlying return on investments of just 6% compared to 58% from the FTSE Vietnam 30 Total Return index that the board used to assess the performance of fund manager VinaCapital. 

Metage, which has pushed for change at private equity fund Pantheon International (PIN) this year, estimates that were it not for the uplift from share buybacks to address the 21% average discount of the past three years, return of net assets would have been zero. 

The activist, which did not disclose its position in VOF, believed that the company’s long-standing investments in unlisted companies, which stood at 12.3% of net asset value (NAV) at the end of September, were a “considerable cause” of both the poor investment return and share price performance. 

Metage also released a letter it had sent to the board on 21 September calling for the company to publish the 10-year performance of the private equity investments before the AGM so shareholders could properly assess them and vote on whether more such investments should be made. 

The VOF board had not provided the requested information and replied on 3 November that it did not consider Metage’s proposals to be in the best interests of shareholders, the activist said. 

Acknowledging VOF’s earlier statement that no new unlisted investments were anticipated until performance recovers, Metage said: “We believe that shareholders, and not the board alone, should decide whether it resumes. All the shareholders we have canvassed, representing a significant portion of the register, oppose any new unlisted investments by the company.”

As at 30 June, according to the annual report last month, value investors City of London and Lazards were the two biggest shareholders with stakes of 14.5% and 13.5% respectively. DIY investors held nearly 11% through Hargreaves Lansdown and Interactive Investor. 

Winterflood analyst Thomas MacRobert said Metage’s intervention increased pressure on the board. “While the recent fee reduction and increased buybacks represent positive steps on alignment and capital allocation, the key issue remains whether the board can demonstrate that the remaining unlisted exposure is creating value and does not continue to constrain the fund’s rating or future exit options.”

In June VOF cut VinaCapital’s annual management fee by 23% and scrapped the 10% performance the Ho Chi Minh City-based fund manager could earn if NAV grew more than 10% in a year. It also said the benchmark would transition to the FTSE Vietnam All-Share index over four years. 

Kathryn Matthews, the former Fidelity Asia chief investment officer who replaced Hugh Evans as chair last December, will earn $118,450 (£89,701) this year, according to the annual report. 

In the report Matthews said that the cap on directors pay had not changed since 2018. While directors fees had risen with inflation, she said the hike in the ceiling was necessary to recruit new directors and to afford overlaps between incoming and outgoing directors as the board looks for successors to replace senior independent director John Healy and herself next year. They joined VOF in 2018 and 2019 respectively. 

VOF shares added 3.3p or 0.8% to 430.35 this morning, 18.9% below their last NAV per share of 530p ($703 cents) on 12 November.

The past five years have been difficult for VOF and its two London-listed rivals Vietnam Holding (VNH) and Vietnam Enterprise (VEIL). VOF shareholders have seen a 7% total loss with dividends included, compared to 3% and 6% drops for VNH and VEIL.

Urging fellow shareholders to consider voting against the directors’ fee cap hike, Childs said the board’s disregard for shareholders’ views on private equity indicated a broader misalignment that extended to pay. “We cannot believe that any board having overseen an underperformance of 58 percentage points against its own chosen benchmark would ask shareholders to raise the cap on its fees by 30%,” he said.

Gavin Lumsden
Written By Gavin Lumsden

Head of News

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *